You’re Killing Me

You’re Killing Me is an American mystery-comedy-drama created by Robin Bernheim that premiered on Acorn TV on 18 May 2026, before also becoming available via Prime Video and AMC+. Set in the fictional Maine town of Founders’ Cove, the series stars Brooke Shields (The Blue Lagoon, Suddenly Susan) as Allie Chandler, a bestselling crime novelist whose fictional plotting suddenly collides with real, personal tragedy when a close friend is murdered. Amalia Williamson co-stars as Andi Walker, an aspiring young writer and true crime podcaster whose obsessive knowledge of the genre’s tropes and techniques makes her an unexpectedly effective—if occasionally over-eager—investigative partner for the more experienced Allie.

The series’ premise plays with genuinely knowing, self-aware humour: a professional crime novelist, whose entire career has been built on inventing fictional murders and solving them on the page, suddenly finds herself confronting a real one on her own doorstep. This central irony—Allie’s expertise in plotting the perfect fictional crime proving both invaluable and occasionally misleading when applied to messy, unpredictable reality—gives the show a distinctive comic-mystery tone that sits somewhere between traditional cosy crime and knowing meta-commentary on the genre itself. Andi, meanwhile, brings the modern true-crime podcast sensibility to the partnership—internet research skills, an instinct for narrative hooks, and a occasionally over-enthusiastic willingness to pursue leads that a more cautious investigator might avoid.

Standing in their way, and gradually becoming an ally despite himself, is Detective Jack Kerrigan (Tom Cavanagh, The Flash, Ed), the new lead detective of Founders’ Cove’s small local police department. A former city detective struggling to acclimate to small-town policing—where everyone knows everyone, gossip travels faster than official investigation, and amateur sleuths keep interfering with his crime scenes—Jack provides both comic friction and grudging professional respect as the season unfolds. The show mines considerable comedy from the culture clash between Jack’s more conventional, procedure-focused policing and Allie and Andi’s freewheeling, novelistic approach to detection, whilst still delivering genuine mystery plotting and escalating stakes as the body count in Founders’ Cove continues to rise.

The six-episode first series follows Allie’s investigation into her friend’s suspicious death, building toward a season finale that sends Allie and Andi on a perilous road trip chasing a promising new lead on the whereabouts of Andi’s long-missing mother—revealing that the pair aren’t the only ones searching for this mysterious woman, and that their sleuthing has inadvertently placed them in genuine danger after they discover a body connected to one of their earlier cases. This blend of the show’s lighter, comedic case-of-the-week format with a more serialised, personally stakes-driven mystery running underneath gives You’re Killing Me a structure similar to other successful modern amateur-sleuth partnerships, whilst its small-town Maine setting and central female friendship distinguish its particular flavour within the genre.

The supporting cast includes Carlo Rota as Ronald, Bob Mann as Martin Adams, Laura Kohoot as Connie Newsome, Gabriel Burrafato as Norman Baights, and Natalie Brown as Melissa Grant, populating Founders’ Cove with the kind of richly eccentric small-town characters familiar from the amateur-sleuth cosy crime tradition. Direction across the first series was shared between James Genn, Scott Smith, and Paul Fox, with writing credited to Walker Hare and Brad Martocello alongside creator Robin Bernheim, who also serves as showrunner.

Critical response to the show’s chemistry has been notably positive, with reviewers particularly praising the on-screen partnership between Shields and Williamson, describing their dynamic as “stellar” and noting Shields’s poised, comfortable command of the material. Reviews have highlighted the show’s effective pacing, well-placed twists, and its willingness to explore Allie’s troubled past and how it shapes her approach to crime-solving, adding emotional depth beyond straightforward comic mystery plotting. The series has been praised for blending emotional storylines with mystery in a way that elevates the broader genre, using deliberate technical choices—atmospheric lighting, considered camera work, and moody sound design—to establish a tone darker and more suspenseful than its central comic partnership might initially suggest.

Following its well-received first series, You’re Killing Me was renewed for a second series, confirmed to remain set in Founders’ Cove, with Cavanagh’s Detective Jack continuing to navigate both small-town policing and his complicated professional relationship with Allie and Andi. As of the time of writing, further Season 2 details—including whether Andi’s mother mystery resolves and how the central trio’s dynamic evolves—remain to be revealed, though the show’s strong critical reception and swift renewal suggest Founders’ Cove’s murder rate, much like so many of its cosy crime predecessors, shows little sign of slowing down.

Yes, just Register and you will then be able to add notes to every character. Just click/tap on the character. The notes can only be seen by you (when you are Logged In)